Second opinion: Secretary for Education Michael Suen announces the Government's decision to seek a judicial review on the findings of the report of the Commission of Inquiry on Allegations relating to the Hong Kong Institute of Education.

The Government has applied for leave for a judicial review on part of the findings of the report of the Commission of Inquiry on Allegations relating to the Hong Kong Institute of Education.

The report concluded that direct contact of a senior government official with academic members to express their opinion on or to protest against the critical views of the members, even without any threat of sanction or reprisal, would constitute improper interference with academic freedom.

However, Secretary for Education Michael Suen said part of the findings are legally flawed and will affect future dealings between government officials and academic institutions and the formulation and implementation of education policies.

"Legal advice has [indicated] that the findings of the commission are wrong in law and in principle. Having sought the advice of the Department of Justice, the Education Bureau considers it necessary to launch a judicial review on that part of the findings."

Mr Suen said it is established practice for the Government to consult different stakeholders in the formulation of policies to balance the needs of different social sectors and ensure policies work in the overall community interest.

During the implementation of policies the Education Bureau will need to engage and discuss with different stakeholders, and even debate on dissenting views, to ensure smooth implementation of policies, he added.